Keto Pumpkin Desserts
Recipe Round-Up

Keto Pumpkin Desserts

Pumpkin is the easy part. It is the sugar and wheat flour around it that turn a slice into a problem, so swap those two and the season opens right back up. Thirty keto pumpkin desserts from people who bake low-carb every week, from crustless pie to no-churn ice cream.

The centerpiece

Keto Pumpkin Pies & Tarts

Pie is the easy one to fix. Swap the crust and the sugar, and the custard does exactly what it always did.

Cream cheese season

Keto Pumpkin Cheesecakes

Cream cheese was keto before keto had a name. These just add pumpkin, warm spice and a nut crust.

FROM OUR PANTRY

Sweet enough to fool the family

Allulose tastes and bakes like real sugar, with 0 net carbs and none of the cooling aftertaste. It browns and caramelizes too, which is the part keto pumpkin pie has always been missing. Reach for it anywhere these recipes call for a granulated sweetener.

Allulose (11.3 oz)
The scoop

The Scoop on our Allulose

A naturally occurring sweetener with the same taste and texture as traditional sugar but none of the downsides. Keto-friendly, with 0 net carbs and virtually 0 calories.

  • Zero Net Carbs
  • 90% Fewer Calories
  • No Aftertaste
  • Free shipping on orders over $30
Shop Allulose
Got questions?

We've Got Answers

Is pumpkin keto-friendly?

In dessert amounts, yes. A cup of plain canned pumpkin puree runs about 12 grams of net carbs, and most of these recipes split that cup across eight or more servings, so the pumpkin adds only a couple of grams per slice. Buy plain puree, not pumpkin pie filling, which comes pre-sweetened with sugar.

What is the best sweetener for keto pumpkin pie?

One that browns. Allulose tastes and bakes like real sugar with 0 net carbs and no cooling aftertaste, and it caramelizes, so the custard sets with the color of a regular pie. It browns faster than sugar does, so tent the crust with foil for the last 15 minutes. Erythritol blends work too, though some bakers notice a cooling finish.

Why did my keto pumpkin dessert turn out wet or gummy?

Pumpkin is mostly water, and low-carb flours soak up liquid differently from wheat. Blot the puree between paper towels, or cook it down on the stove for five minutes, before you measure it. Then let the bake cool completely, since custards and cheesecakes finish setting in the fridge. A tablespoon of Oat Fiber in a bread or bar batter holds moisture without turning it gummy.

Should I use almond, coconut, or lupin flour?

Almond flour is the default for crusts and cheesecake bases, because its fat presses and bakes like a graham crust. Coconut flour drinks liquid, so use about a quarter as much and add an extra egg. Lupin Flour, at 1g net carb per serving, brings structure to cakes and cookies, and it works best mixed half and half with almond flour.

Can I make keto pumpkin pie without a crust?

Yes, and it is the easiest win on this page. Grease a pie dish, pour in the filling, and bake at 325°F until the center barely jiggles. A crustless pie skips the rolling and pressing entirely, and it slices clean once it has chilled overnight.

How do I store and freeze keto pumpkin desserts?

Pies, cheesecakes and bars keep in the fridge, covered, for four to five days. Cheesecake and bars freeze well for up to three months - wrap slices one by one and thaw them overnight in the fridge. Custard pies freeze less gracefully because the filling weeps as it thaws, so bake those a day or two before you serve them.