Christmas Dessert Recipes
Recipe Round-Up

Christmas Dessert Recipes

The cookie tin has its own pages. These 30 Christmas dessert recipes are for the table after dinner, from a cranberry curd tart and sticky toffee pudding to a pavlova wreath and gingerbread tiramisu. Most of them are made a day ahead, so Christmas Day is just slicing.

Bring a pie

Christmas Pies and Tarts

Six pies and tarts that look like December, from a ruby cranberry curd tart to Britain's mince pies. Most bake a day ahead and slice better cold.

FROM OUR PANTRY

One spoonful, deeper chocolate

Stir a teaspoon of Espresso Powder into a chocolate mousse or a pots de creme base and the chocolate tastes darker and rounder, with no coffee flavor muscling in. It's pure, finely ground espresso that dissolves completely, so nothing gritty ends up in a silky dessert. On tiramisu night, it doubles as the soak.

Spoons out

Christmas Puddings and Trifles

Puddings are the oldest Christmas desserts on the books. Here are four, from a sticky toffee dome to a Danish rice pudding with a hidden almond, plus two trifles built to feed a room.

Crisp outside, soft inside

Pavlovas and Meringue Showpieces

Meringue is mostly egg whites, sugar and patience, and it turns into the showiest thing on the table. Wreaths, a roulade and one baked alaska with its own little forest.

No oven needed

Chilled, Frozen and No-Bake Desserts

When the oven is full of dinner, these set in the fridge or freezer instead. Two gingerbread tiramisus, a chai panna cotta, a semifreddo, eggnog ice cream and an icebox cake.

Espresso Powder (7 oz)
The scoop

The Scoop on our Espresso Powder

The king of improving the chocolate flavor of your favorite desserts - without adding coffee flavor or bitterness. Cakes, cookies, tiramisu, truffles, brownies, and more.

  • Enhances Chocolate Flavor
  • 100% Pure Coffee
  • Dissolves Completely
  • Free shipping on orders over $30
Shop Espresso Powder
Got questions?

We've Got Answers

What are traditional Christmas desserts?

It depends whose table you're at. Britain has steamed Christmas pudding and mince pies, France has the buche de Noel, Italy has panettone, and Denmark serves risalamande, a cold rice pudding with one whole almond hidden inside for a lucky guest. In the US the classics are pies, cheesecakes and anything with cranberry, gingerbread or peppermint in it.

Which Christmas desserts can I make ahead?

Most of this list. Trifles and tiramisu are better on day two once the layers soak together, and a baked cheesecake keeps three or four days in the fridge. Pie dough freezes for months, and a pavlova shell keeps a day or two in an airtight container. Add the whipped cream, fruit and sauces right before serving.

What is an easy Christmas dessert for a beginner?

Pick one that doesn't need to look perfect. A trifle hides every uneven layer, and bread pudding is mostly stale bread soaked in custard. A no-bake cheesecake is just as forgiving since there's no water bath and nothing to crack. Save the lattice pie and the rolled meringue for a year with a free afternoon.

How many desserts should I make for Christmas dinner?

For 8 to 12 people, two or three is plenty, ideally one chocolate and one fruit. A 9-inch pie or cheesecake cuts into 8 to 12 slices, and a full trifle bowl serves 12 to 16. Guests usually take a sliver of each, so plan on about one and a half servings per person across everything.

How do I keep a pavlova from cracking or weeping?

Bake it low and slow, then turn the oven off and let the meringue cool inside with the door propped open so it shrinks gently. Weeping usually means undissolved sugar, so add it a spoonful at a time and beat until the meringue feels smooth between your fingers. A few cracks on top are normal, and the cream covers them.

How do I bring a pie or trifle to a Christmas party?

Chill it first so the filling sets firm, then carry pies in their plate on a flat surface, like the car floor rather than a seat. Build a trifle in the bowl you'll serve it from and add the whipped cream and topping when you arrive. Cheesecakes travel best in the springform pan with the ring still on.