Christmas Cupcake Ideas
Recipe Round-Up

Christmas Cupcake Ideas

Christmas cupcakes are the tray that gets photographed before it gets eaten. They also forgive a first-time decorator, since a swirl and a sprinkle do most of the work. Twenty-one ideas here, the looks first, piped trees and the Santa-and-reindeer crowd, then the flavors: peppermint, gingerbread and eggnog, hot cocoa and dark chocolate.

FROM OUR PANTRY

Red and green from plants

Press Naturally-Colored Sanding Sugars onto wet frosting and a plain swirl becomes a Christmas cupcake, with no gel color in the bowl. Fine, even crystals in red and green, with color that comes from plants instead of synthetic dyes. Sugar the tray before the frosting sets and it stays put.

The character tray

Santa, Reindeer and Snowman Cupcakes

Santa hats, reindeer faces, two kinds of elf and a snowman rolled in sugar. Most of the work is candy and a piping bag, and small hands can do the candy.

Candy cane season

Peppermint and Candy Cane Cupcakes

Chocolate and peppermint six ways, from a light cream cheese icing to a white chocolate ganache center. Crushed candy canes go on at the end, every time.

Chocolate Cupcakes with Peppermint Icing

Chocolate Cupcakes with Peppermint Icing

Brown sugar and buttermilk keep this chocolate cupcake light, and the icing is a cream cheese and peppermint whip instead of a heavy buttercream. Crushed candy canes finish it.

Lori Lange, Recipe Girl View Recipe →
Peppermint Red Velvet Cupcakes

Peppermint Red Velvet Cupcakes

No mixer needed: an oil-based red velvet with peppermint in the batter and in the buttercream. Red cake, white swirl, crushed candy cane on top, and it reads as a candy cane before you add one.

Gayle Bialas, Pumpkin 'N Spice View Recipe →
Peppermint Mocha Latte Cupcakes

Peppermint Mocha Latte Cupcakes

Dutch-process cocoa and a packet of instant coffee in the batter, peppermint buttercream over it. Espresso Powder does the same job without the packet, and dissolves cleaner.

Sarah Walker Caron, Sarah's Cucina Bella View Recipe →
Candy Cane Cupcakes

Candy Cane Cupcakes

Cocoa bloomed in boiling water makes a dark, tender crumb, and a mini candy cane stuck in the peppermint buttercream does the decorating. The simplest card in the section.

Nickki Thompson, Something Sweet Something Savoury View Recipe →
White Chocolate Peppermint Cupcakes

White Chocolate Peppermint Cupcakes

The bakery one: egg-white peppermint cupcakes on cake flour, a white chocolate peppermint ganache hidden in the middle, white chocolate buttercream and crushed candy canes. Worth the three components.

Ginny Dyer, In Bloom Bakery View Recipe →
Peppermint Mocha Cupcakes

Peppermint Mocha Cupcakes

Hot coffee and cocoa in the cupcake, peppermint Swiss meringue buttercream on top, and a drizzle of dark chocolate over the swirl. Silkier than American buttercream and far less sweet.

Zainab Mansaray, A Classic Twist View Recipe →
Naturally-Colored Sanding Sugars
The scoop

The Scoop on our Naturally-Colored Sanding Sugars

Skip the synthetic dyes - our sanding sugar gets bold color from plants. Perfect for cookies, cocktails, and desserts that deserve better ingredients.

  • Naturally Colored
  • Fine Grained
  • No Artificial Dyes
  • Free shipping on orders over $30
Shop Naturally-Colored Sanding Sugars
Got questions?

We've Got Answers

How do I pipe a Christmas tree on a cupcake?

Use an open star tip and frosting stiff enough to hold a ridge. Pipe a ring around the outside edge, then a smaller ring on top of it, and keep pulling up and inward until you reach a point. Three or four rings make a tree. A tablespoon of Meringue Powder in the buttercream helps the ridges hold at room temperature, and ten minutes in the fridge before the sprinkles go on keeps the tree from squashing when you press.

How do I get red and green frosting without a bitter taste or bleeding color?

Use gel color, never liquid, and add less than you think: a deep red keeps darkening for hours after you mix it, so tint it the night before and you will use less. Green behaves and can be mixed on the day. If you would rather keep color out of the bowl entirely, frost white and press Naturally-Colored Sanding Sugars onto the wet frosting. The red and green come from plants, and the color sits on top of the cupcake instead of in it.

Can I bake Christmas cupcakes ahead and freeze them?

Yes, unfrosted. Cool them completely, freeze them in a single layer, then bag them for up to a month. Thaw in the liners on the counter for an hour and frost the day you serve. Cupcakes frosted with American buttercream freeze too, but piped trees, sprinkles and toppers suffer in the freezer, so decorate after thawing. Cream cheese frosting always goes on fresh.

Which frosting holds up best on a decorated cupcake?

American buttercream, for anything piped or covered in sprinkles. It sets a light crust and takes a tree or a tall swirl without slumping. Cream cheese frosting belongs on gingerbread and eggnog cupcakes for the flavor, but it softens fast, so keep it cold and pipe it last. Whipped cream is the softest of the three and is a same-day frosting. A tablespoon of Meringue Powder gives any of them a firmer set.

How do I make a chocolate cupcake dark enough for Christmas?

Swap a third to half of the cocoa in the recipe for Black Cocoa. The crumb bakes near-black with little to no food coloring, and the flavor goes deep and smooth with that classic sandwich-cookie note. Keep the rest Dutch-Process for its rounded chocolate flavor. If the recipe is built on natural cocoa and baking soda, keep some natural cocoa in the mix, since the soda needs its acidity to lift the batter. A teaspoon of Espresso Powder behind it all makes the chocolate taste more like chocolate without tasting like coffee.

How do I transport decorated cupcakes without wrecking them?

Chill them first. Thirty minutes in the fridge sets buttercream enough to survive the drive. Use a cupcake carrier, or set the liners back into the muffin tin and cover it, so nothing slides. Keep the tin flat on the floor of the car, and pack anything that sticks up, like candy canes, pretzel antlers and sugar-cone trees, in a bag to add when you arrive. Sprinkles and sanding sugar travel fine on their own.